Springfield 1911 Garrison
+11
Grouse
James Hensler
zanemoseley
Lightfoot
knightimac
kc.crawford.7
Merick
Skid
javaduke
BE Mike
desben
15 posters
Page 1 of 1
Springfield 1911 Garrison
A couple of weeks ago, Springfield Armory launched a new line of 1911 called the "Garrison". Beavertail, blued finish, novak sights, for an MSRP of $800. In many ways similar to what the Range Officer was. Now, if only they would release a Garrison Target with Bo-Mar sights, we'd have a new winner to recommend to those wanting to get into bullseye.
https://www.springfield-armory.com/1911-series-handguns/1911-garrison-handguns/
https://www.springfield-armory.com/1911-series-handguns/1911-garrison-handguns/
desben- Posts : 385
Join date : 2013-12-22
Location : Ontario, Canada
knightimac and orpheoet like this post
Re: Springfield 1911 Garrison
With the SA Loaded Target you get a "match grade barrel" and adjustable sights for MSRP of $1,065.
BE Mike- Posts : 2564
Join date : 2011-07-29
Location : Indiana
knightimac likes this post
Re: Springfield 1911 Garrison
The Garrison also has a "match grade" barrel, but the wrong sights. The Loaded has Bo-Mar sights, but only in stainless; no target version in carbon steel.
desben- Posts : 385
Join date : 2013-12-22
Location : Ontario, Canada
knightimac likes this post
Re: Springfield 1911 Garrison
One option might be to use the "Nomar" base: https://www.bunkerarms.com/product-page/nomar-conversion-base
But I really don't get it why most manufacturers these days use the Novak fixed sights. I guess they are cheaper to manufacture?
But I really don't get it why most manufacturers these days use the Novak fixed sights. I guess they are cheaper to manufacture?
Re: Springfield 1911 Garrison
I had about the same idea, why not find out what rear sight cut Springfield used and use a sight pusher and remove the Novak sight and replace it with a adjustable rear that fits.
Skid- Posts : 282
Join date : 2014-05-19
Age : 62
Location : Northern Lower Mi
Re: Springfield 1911 Garrison
If it makes you feel any better, springfield uses their own crazy dimensions and not novak's. Or maybe novak rear and Dan Wesson front? I don't remember the details, but they made it harder than it had to be for no reason.
Also I wonder if the slim grips have the slim grip bushings instead of the standard ones?
Also I wonder if the slim grips have the slim grip bushings instead of the standard ones?
Merick- Posts : 452
Join date : 2015-08-13
Location : Kansas
knightimac likes this post
Re: Springfield 1911 Garrison
The reason they have to do that is they didn't want to pay royalties to Novak for the use of his sight cut. Or so that is my understanding.Merick wrote:If it makes you feel any better, springfield uses their own crazy dimensions and not novak's. Or maybe novak rear and Dan Wesson front? I don't remember the details, but they made it harder than it had to be for no reason.
Also I wonder if the slim grips have the slim grip bushings instead of the standard ones?
knightimac likes this post
Re: Springfield 1911 Garrison
I'm thankful to have found a new Range Officer 45 at a local gun store a few weeks ago for $850. It only took 15 phone calls within a 50 mile radius to locate a one. Now I plan on shooting it alot rather than chasing more expensive or used equipment.
The Garrison seems like a good choice for a slide rail and dot. The Ronin may be Ok too for build.
One thing I love about the few Springfields that I've owned they just seem to run and shoot well out of the box.
The Garrison seems like a good choice for a slide rail and dot. The Ronin may be Ok too for build.
One thing I love about the few Springfields that I've owned they just seem to run and shoot well out of the box.
knightimac- Posts : 215
Join date : 2014-03-16
Location : Auburn, Pa
Fotomaniac and popchevy like this post
Re: Springfield 1911 Garrison
This is a possible option, but in my opinion the NOMAR is pretty expensive as a plan A. In a perfect world buy a gun with the right cut from the factory. With milling, the NOMAR will cost over $250. I started a build with a Novak cut then changed my mind mid stream to make it a ball gun. The NOMAR is the perfect "plan b" for something like this. Had I not already fit the slide and barrel, It would have been way cheaper to start with the right slide.javaduke wrote:One option might be to use the "Nomar" base: https://www.bunkerarms.com/product-page/nomar-conversion-base
But I really don't get it why most manufacturers these days use the Novak fixed sights. I guess they are cheaper to manufacture?
Lightfoot- Posts : 230
Join date : 2016-08-07
Location : Aggieland TX
Re: Springfield 1911 Garrison
Hmm, I' wondering if it's possible to machine a custom base which accepts the Bomar blade and fits in the existing slide cut. The only downside seems to be that it will sit a bit higher which will require a taller front sight.
I've never tried it before, so I don't know if there are any technical limitations.
I've never tried it before, so I don't know if there are any technical limitations.
Re: Springfield 1911 Garrison
This crap is one of the reasons I just have Jon build me custom guns now, especially if you're adding a rail so you you don't see old sight cuts. If you want a good gun you're usually going to trash the stock ignition parts, barrel, bushing and slide stop. Then you get to deal with the factory slide to frame fit. At least the new SA models are blued instead of parked, wasn't a fan of the RO finish. The RO Elite had the nicer ceramic coating but think its gone now too.
zanemoseley- Posts : 2688
Join date : 2015-07-11
Location : Cookeville, TN
Re: Springfield 1911 Garrison
Option one
Call Springfield order the Garrison and add the Bo-mar rear.
Call Springfield order the Garrison and add the Bo-mar rear.
James Hensler- Posts : 1245
Join date : 2018-01-15
Age : 55
Location : Southwest Florida
knightimac and Fotomaniac like this post
Re: Springfield 1911 Garrison
Newbie here. For curiosity sake....what would it take to make the Garrison a decent Bullseye gun? With or without a red dot. Who would you send it to?
Grouse- Posts : 49
Join date : 2018-01-25
Location : Canton, Ohio
Re: Springfield 1911 Garrison
I started with a new RO , put a dot on it and adjusted the trigger. It shoots pretty good as is. My advice is to do the same ,get good with it THEN soup it up. Thats how I am approaching this game. I am fairly new at this also, I just started last summer and am having a ball !
popchevy- Posts : 131
Join date : 2021-03-19
Re: Springfield 1911 Garrison
The two garrisons I looked at were pretty tight frame /slide fit. Triggers weren't so great. You can put a LPA adj rear sight in the Novak cut.
Loaded is better bang for buck, have one with lpa adj rear added. The two Garrisons were 739 next shelf down was a like new SA loaded for 729 I have another loaded now , wanted a Novak sight one.
Loaded is better bang for buck, have one with lpa adj rear added. The two Garrisons were 739 next shelf down was a like new SA loaded for 729 I have another loaded now , wanted a Novak sight one.
Tangeant- Posts : 25
Join date : 2015-11-03
Re: Springfield 1911 Garrison
If you are going with a dot sight just get a SA milspec, it has a carbon steel frame and slide. You can upgrade the barrel and bushing. I have one that was done by Dave Salyer then re-done with some additional changes by a smith I know and it is a really nice shooting pistol.
troystaten- Posts : 823
Join date : 2012-04-18
Grouse likes this post
Re: Springfield 1911 Garrison
[quote="troystaten"]If you are going with a dot sight just get a SA milspec, it has a carbon steel frame and slide. You can upgrade the barrel and bushing. I have one that was done by Dave Salyer then re-done with some additional changes by a smith I know and it is a really nice shooting pistol.[/quote]
I only have one of each, a RO and a MilSpec, as a basis for my opinion. But the MilSpec has a tighter frame-slide fit (.002-.003 vert and horiz at both front and rear) than the RO. And a rail will completely cover the small rear dovetail of the MilSpec. If you shoot irons, you get an extra bit of sight radius when you set up the slide with an old-school high mount Kensight (BoMar copy) rear or heave rib Even better.
If all MilSpec guns now are as well fit off the shelf, as the RO ever was, we are no worse off than before the RO was discontinued. You just have to drop your MilSpec in the stones a few times to distract you from the ugly, factory finish. It feels like six-hundred grit sandpaper. I can use the side of the slide as a sharpening stone. :lol:
I only have one of each, a RO and a MilSpec, as a basis for my opinion. But the MilSpec has a tighter frame-slide fit (.002-.003 vert and horiz at both front and rear) than the RO. And a rail will completely cover the small rear dovetail of the MilSpec. If you shoot irons, you get an extra bit of sight radius when you set up the slide with an old-school high mount Kensight (BoMar copy) rear or heave rib Even better.
If all MilSpec guns now are as well fit off the shelf, as the RO ever was, we are no worse off than before the RO was discontinued. You just have to drop your MilSpec in the stones a few times to distract you from the ugly, factory finish. It feels like six-hundred grit sandpaper. I can use the side of the slide as a sharpening stone. :lol:
inthebeech- Posts : 652
Join date : 2012-03-17
Age : 59
Location : Harleysville, Pennsylvania
troystaten and Grouse like this post
Similar topics
» Springfield Armory's Garrison - Suitable Replacement for Range Officer?
» EB Adjustable sight does not work with SA Garrison 1911
» Springfield 1911-A1 or Remington 1911 R1
» Springfield NM 1911-A1
» Springfield Armory 1911
» EB Adjustable sight does not work with SA Garrison 1911
» Springfield 1911-A1 or Remington 1911 R1
» Springfield NM 1911-A1
» Springfield Armory 1911
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|