Small Primer vs Large Primer 45 ACP Benchmark
+2
Wobbley
Orion
6 posters
Page 1 of 1
Small Primer vs Large Primer 45 ACP Benchmark
Was reading this article where the author benchmarks small and large primers for 45 ACP. Looks his accuracy varies across primer loads.
What are your thoughts on this benchmark? Has anyone seen differences in accuracy when using small vs large primers?
The sample is way too small..
https://www.shootingtimes.com/editorial/small-vs-large-pistol-primers-45-acp/99626
What are your thoughts on this benchmark? Has anyone seen differences in accuracy when using small vs large primers?
The sample is way too small..
https://www.shootingtimes.com/editorial/small-vs-large-pistol-primers-45-acp/99626
Re: Small Primer vs Large Primer 45 ACP Benchmark
The picture with the gun was shot with large primers and 200 grain Brazos slow fire, the one without was shot with small primers and 180 grain Brazos at a timed fire pace. The accuracy of these loads is near-as-dammit identical. I keep the brass segregated for obvious reasons, but small or large primers are insignificant in accuracy.
Wobbley- Admin
- Posts : 4808
Join date : 2015-02-13
Re: Small Primer vs Large Primer 45 ACP Benchmark
I don't see any real difference in accuracy in the table in the article. Based on that data, I think the answer is: no difference. But there are more rigorous ways to test accuracy than what he did. Ransom Rest, and more shots fired.
S148- Posts : 319
Join date : 2017-07-04
Re: Small Primer vs Large Primer 45 ACP Benchmark
When using small primers I do see some extra unburnt powder, does anyone else notice this? Moving to magnum primers seems to help.
Ray Dash- Posts : 335
Join date : 2019-01-31
Location : NY
Re: Small Primer vs Large Primer 45 ACP Benchmark
In general ignore any accuracy claims / tests in the general gun media. Five shot groups are not enough to have confidence in the results and they don't use barrel fixtures or accurized guns.
Steve B and BE Mike like this post
Re: Small Primer vs Large Primer 45 ACP Benchmark
I tested out 30-40 small primer 45 rounds at the range this week. All but 2 rounds cycled in my LBC properly.
Load data: Berry's 185 SWC, range(3.9, 4.0, 4.1) WST, 1.185 OAL, light crimp, range brass and small Winchester primers.
I have no issues with this load using large pistol primers.
Any thoughts why this might be?
Load data: Berry's 185 SWC, range(3.9, 4.0, 4.1) WST, 1.185 OAL, light crimp, range brass and small Winchester primers.
I have no issues with this load using large pistol primers.
Any thoughts why this might be?
Re: Small Primer vs Large Primer 45 ACP Benchmark
Small primers will most likely have less priming material, so it may not ignite the powder as thoroughly resulting in a slower burn and less energy in the bullet, and less recoil energy.Orion wrote:Any thoughts why this might be?
It's also possible the flash holes are partially blocked or some other brass difference.
Re: Small Primer vs Large Primer 45 ACP Benchmark
I have found using small pistol primers I need to slightly increase the powder charge to equal my large primer load. My standard load using large pistol primers is 3.8 gr Clays and a 185 LSWC and with small pistol primers 4.1 gr Clays and a 185 LSWC.
JB
JB
Johnnie.Bair- Posts : 15
Join date : 2011-10-17
Similar topics
» sorting large, and small primer 45acp??
» small primer .45 acp
» 45 acp small primer brass - Fr&@>*¥?!!
» Loading small primer .45
» I hate Federal 45 small pistol primers
» small primer .45 acp
» 45 acp small primer brass - Fr&@>*¥?!!
» Loading small primer .45
» I hate Federal 45 small pistol primers
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum