Using Lead and FMJ in match
+7
spursnguns
Jack H
Jerry Keefer
BE Mike
kc.crawford.7
Schaumannk
Otiso
11 posters
Page 1 of 1
Using Lead and FMJ in match
Would there be any problems using FMJ for slow fire and lead for timed and rapid? I shot 50 lead rounds the other day, and after looking through the barrel, I can't see any leading.
Otiso- Posts : 54
Join date : 2014-05-27
Re: Using Lead and FMJ in match
A lot of people do that. I would prefer to shoot lead all the way through the match. However, with my 9mm centerfire gun, I cant find any lead ammo that is accurate at the fifty yard line.
As long as you check for leading and clean often enough to prevent lead buildup in the barrel, you should not have a problem.
As long as you check for leading and clean often enough to prevent lead buildup in the barrel, you should not have a problem.
Schaumannk- Posts : 615
Join date : 2011-06-11
Location : Cheyenne, WY
Re: Using Lead and FMJ in match
While it is true that "many" people do shoot jacketed on the long line and lead on the short line, you ARE creating a problem. You're going to have guilded metal fouling in the barrel from your slow fire strings. Then you're going to put lead fouling on top of your metal fouling. It makes cleaning the barrel much more difficult. The only way I know of to completely clean a barrel that has been shot like that is electo-chemical (Foul Out) to get all the fouling out of the barrel. And then you're going to have to "season" the barrel again to get your best accuracy.
I use Fire Clean on every barrel that comes through my shop. That will make it easier to clean and help minimize fouling; both guilded metal, lead and powder. Just my opinion.
I use Fire Clean on every barrel that comes through my shop. That will make it easier to clean and help minimize fouling; both guilded metal, lead and powder. Just my opinion.
Re: Using Lead and FMJ in match
Back in the day, I shot a lot of matches, using the Nosler 185 gr. JHP for slow fire and 185 gr. LSWCHP for the short line. I used the 1911 for both centerfire and .45 matches. I often shot my first slow fire in in the .45 match with a score in the mid to high nineties. I use old school methods to clean the barrel, i.e. Hoppe's Elite Bore Cleaner. When I first started using Hoppe's Elite, I thoroughly cleaned the barrel as recommended. I don't know if it mattered or not. I'm not disputing kc's assertions, I'm only saying that shooting lead after jacketed and then jacketed (without) cleaning, didn't seem to hurt my scores. I have Kart barrels. YMMV
BE Mike- Posts : 2589
Join date : 2011-07-29
Location : Indiana
Re: Using Lead and FMJ in match
David Sams has given the same advice as KC..at clinics. Along with the warning that lead in the barrel increases pressures as the jacketed round passes thru and over the lead. I used to do it, but I have completely returned to (cast) lead, long and short line.. I started shooting BE in the mid 1960s and lead dominated the game back then.. Very good scores were fired. A good gun and good lead will shoot under 2 inches at 50.. The cost savings and wear and tear on the shooter/gun, makes (cast) lead definitely worth considering..
Jerry
Jerry
Jerry Keefer- Posts : 1001
Join date : 2012-01-02
Location : Maidens, VA
Re: Using Lead and FMJ in match
Is it feasible to shoot your jacketed Noslers/Zero types at 50, and use plated (Berry's?) at 25?
Jack H- Posts : 2699
Join date : 2011-06-10
Age : 75
Location : Oregon
Re: Using Lead and FMJ in match
I think David Sams is obsessed with accuracy. Not a bad trait in a gunsmith, but for the unsupported shooter out on the line, life is a series of trade offs.
Very few of us can shoot up to the limits of accuracy in a good bullseye gun.
If your gun absolutely won't hold the ten ring at the fifty yard line, without jacketed ammo, and you can't afford to shoot jacketed at the short line, I would make that trade off.
Very few of us can shoot up to the limits of accuracy in a good bullseye gun.
If your gun absolutely won't hold the ten ring at the fifty yard line, without jacketed ammo, and you can't afford to shoot jacketed at the short line, I would make that trade off.
Schaumannk- Posts : 615
Join date : 2011-06-11
Location : Cheyenne, WY
Re: Using Lead and FMJ in match
Jack H wrote:Is it feasible to shoot your jacketed Noslers/Zero types at 50, and use plated (Berry's?) at 25?
While there are exceptions; most shooters find plated bullets lacking in the accuracy department.
Jim
spursnguns- Posts : 611
Join date : 2013-01-04
Age : 66
Location : Nampa, Idaho
Re: Using Lead and FMJ in match
A few years back Berry's sent me a sample of their plated 185 gr HBRN bullets. While the accuracy was good, it did not group as well as 200 gr LSWC or Zero 185 gr LHP at either the short or long line.
AllAces- Posts : 745
Join date : 2011-08-30
Re: Using Lead and FMJ in match
I have friends that do it, and they clean the barrel after each 2700, as long as you don't let it build and build over several matches its been no problem for them, however unless you are so good as to be able to take advantage of the minor gains in accuracy of the FMJ-then its a waste of time and money and effort. My lead loaded 185s produce 2'' 50 yd groups, my zero fmj-hps do 1.5'' @ 50yds, unless your a 2600 + shooter you will never see an advantage. If money is not a factor shoot the fmjs the whole match. Another issue I found with mixing, fmjs and lead require not only elevation adjustments but windage as well when going to the short line, making for more needed steps to keep up with during a match.
DavidR- Admin
- Posts : 3032
Join date : 2011-06-10
Age : 70
Location : NRA:Expert, Georgia
Re: Using Lead and FMJ in match
I use Zero or Nosler 185 SWC on long line and lead on the short. I run a bore snake through the barrel between them and clean the gun after every 2700 with Shooters Choice Lead Remover.
I have considered going to one or the other exclusively for the sole reason of making my reloading life a bit easier but everything works perfect for me right now. DavidR is correct in that you are more likely to have to make a windage adjustment.
My opinion is that you should not base a shooting decision on your score. If you can afford it and its proven more accurate, then do it.
I have considered going to one or the other exclusively for the sole reason of making my reloading life a bit easier but everything works perfect for me right now. DavidR is correct in that you are more likely to have to make a windage adjustment.
My opinion is that you should not base a shooting decision on your score. If you can afford it and its proven more accurate, then do it.
sixftunda- Posts : 455
Join date : 2012-05-18
Age : 52
Location : North Central Ohio
Re: Using Lead and FMJ in match
Knowing that my gun and ammo is accurate puts any doubt about what caused that bad shot at rest. This game is 90% mental. The rest is in your head.
BE Mike- Posts : 2589
Join date : 2011-07-29
Location : Indiana
Re: Using Lead and FMJ in match
IME, a good-fitting lead bullet with any of a number of decent lubes will leave such an insignificant amount of lead in ONLY the throat, that you really don't need to clean and don't see any accuracy drop-off for several hundred rounds.
.45 and .38 Special (yeah. .357 too). I just have not been able to get BE level accuracy out of ANY 9mms yet, but that is with a stock SIG P226.
Last time I cleaned, it was literally 3 patches of bore cleaner, then 30 or so strokes with a bronze brush, then another 4-5 patches to finish up, including the light oil patch. About than 10 minutes, including the slide and other surfaces which have to be done if shooting jacketed anyway.
AFAIC, if you know your zeros, go for it.
I'm also with those who found plated bullets to rarely match the accuracy of a good lead or a good jacketed bullet. Best results were in .38/.357, worst in .40, and .45 were also pretty bad, like 4 inches at 25 yards with the .45.
.45 and .38 Special (yeah. .357 too). I just have not been able to get BE level accuracy out of ANY 9mms yet, but that is with a stock SIG P226.
Last time I cleaned, it was literally 3 patches of bore cleaner, then 30 or so strokes with a bronze brush, then another 4-5 patches to finish up, including the light oil patch. About than 10 minutes, including the slide and other surfaces which have to be done if shooting jacketed anyway.
AFAIC, if you know your zeros, go for it.
I'm also with those who found plated bullets to rarely match the accuracy of a good lead or a good jacketed bullet. Best results were in .38/.357, worst in .40, and .45 were also pretty bad, like 4 inches at 25 yards with the .45.
GrumpyOldMan- Posts : 482
Join date : 2013-03-08
Location : High Desert Southwest Red Rock Country
Similar topics
» Jacketed for the long line Lead Wad Cutter for the short line during the same match.
» 38 Special Factory 158gr Lead Semi-Wadcutter or Lead Round Nose For Distinguished Revolver
» ER-773 STANDARD/MATCH Add To Collection .32 S&W Long Wadcutter cal., otherwise similar to ER-772 Match, 2.9 lbs. Imported 1990-95.
» Get The Lead Out
» Trouble with ammo that was recently reloaded...
» 38 Special Factory 158gr Lead Semi-Wadcutter or Lead Round Nose For Distinguished Revolver
» ER-773 STANDARD/MATCH Add To Collection .32 S&W Long Wadcutter cal., otherwise similar to ER-772 Match, 2.9 lbs. Imported 1990-95.
» Get The Lead Out
» Trouble with ammo that was recently reloaded...
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum