Lead deposits in chamber of S&W Model 41
+12
lablover
Sa-tevp
jglenn21
zanemoseley
WesG
Domino1
bruce martindale
SW-52
kc.crawford.7
New2BE
mikemyers
pgg
16 posters
Page 2 of 2
Page 2 of 2 • 1, 2
Lead deposits in chamber of S&W Model 41
First topic message reminder :
On the roof of my model 41's chamber, there is a rough patch. It's right where (I think) the tip of a bullet contacts the chamber as it feeds. This area collects some lead fouling.
I haven't really worried about it, as I'm a minimalist when it comes to cleaning any 22 but this week I had a FTF where the round got stuck halfway in. I wondered if the bullet got stuck on this rough patch.
I've tried cleaning it with some Shooter's Choice lead remover, used a bronze brush, tried some JB paste, really worked at it but there's still a rough patch there. When I run the wooden back end of a Q-tip across it, it definitely still feels rough.
Of late this gun has started to occasionally have a FTE jam. Putting a drop of oil on the first round of every magazine helps but isn't 100%. I suspect having a rough chamber isn't helping matters any.
Clearly visible in the picture below. Any suggestions?
On the roof of my model 41's chamber, there is a rough patch. It's right where (I think) the tip of a bullet contacts the chamber as it feeds. This area collects some lead fouling.
I haven't really worried about it, as I'm a minimalist when it comes to cleaning any 22 but this week I had a FTF where the round got stuck halfway in. I wondered if the bullet got stuck on this rough patch.
I've tried cleaning it with some Shooter's Choice lead remover, used a bronze brush, tried some JB paste, really worked at it but there's still a rough patch there. When I run the wooden back end of a Q-tip across it, it definitely still feels rough.
Of late this gun has started to occasionally have a FTE jam. Putting a drop of oil on the first round of every magazine helps but isn't 100%. I suspect having a rough chamber isn't helping matters any.
Clearly visible in the picture below. Any suggestions?
pgg- Posts : 198
Join date : 2015-11-21
Re: Lead deposits in chamber of S&W Model 41
Sa-tevp wrote:zanemoseley wrote:I'd pay a dollar to know what happened to make that in the first place. Looks like someone took an engraver to your chamber.
I'd guess someone tried to file the feed ramp.
Great guess. I bet that's it. But he's the original owner, I guess it's possible someone at S&W did it but dang.
zanemoseley- Posts : 2688
Join date : 2015-07-11
Location : Cookeville, TN
Re: Lead deposits in chamber of S&W Model 41
It would be interesting to know if the ramp lined up with that - very good theory.Sa-tevp wrote:zanemoseley wrote:I'd pay a dollar to know what happened to make that in the first place. Looks like someone took an engraver to your chamber.
I'd guess someone tried to file the feed ramp.
I thought about jams from Russian steel-cased rounds - because they are in such a seemingly random pattern.
Aprilian- Posts : 987
Join date : 2016-05-13
Location : Minnesota
Re: Lead deposits in chamber of S&W Model 41
If you used the flex hone some more, maybe it will get better? Whatever the flex hone was removing before had to be "above" the surface, not below. Maybe this photo is an illusion, and all the rest is also above the surface? If you do it some more, and nothing changes, that's the end of it, but maybe it will continue to improve?
You used it very briefly, and things improved. Maybe if you continue to use it, it will continue to improve?
You used it very briefly, and things improved. Maybe if you continue to use it, it will continue to improve?
mikemyers- Posts : 4236
Join date : 2016-07-26
Age : 80
Location : South Florida, and India
Re: Lead deposits in chamber of S&W Model 41
I looked at all 4 my 41 barrel ramps. They do not look like what I see here.
Jack H- Posts : 2693
Join date : 2011-06-10
Age : 75
Location : Oregon
Re: Lead deposits in chamber of S&W Model 41
mikemyers wrote:If you used the flex hone some more, maybe it will get better? Whatever the flex hone was removing before had to be "above" the surface, not below. Maybe this photo is an illusion, and all the rest is also above the surface? If you do it some more, and nothing changes, that's the end of it, but maybe it will continue to improve?
You used it very briefly, and things improved. Maybe if you continue to use it, it will continue to improve?
I did some more and it did improve -
First two pictures are reposts just so they're all next to each other in this post. Before, after a brief flex hone spin (maybe 10 seconds), and the last is after another 20-30 seconds of spinning in the chamber. Looking with the borescope, changing the angle and the shadows, these are definitely pits.
I've since put about 400 rounds of CCI SV through the gun without cleaning it. The first two magazines of 5, I didn't put the usual drop of Rem Oil on the 1st round in the magazine, and each magazine had one FTE malfunction. That was typical of the gun since the day I bought it.
After that, I resumed my habit of putting a drop of oil on the 1st round, and the next 400 or so rounds had zero malfunctions. I'm going to declare it fixed and quit messing with it.
Thanks for everyone's suggestions. I suspect I caused this damage cleaning the feed ramp with a brush that had a steel core, though I honestly can't remember ever owning such a tool or attacking the feed ramp that violently. I can't think of any other plausible way it could have happened though.
pgg- Posts : 198
Join date : 2015-11-21
Re: Lead deposits in chamber of S&W Model 41
Could that have been there from the factory? I don't see that in any of my Model 41 barrels, I have a factory optics barrel, a 7 3/8 inch barrel, a 5-inch field barrel, and 2 5 1/2inch EFS barrels. I can't imagine what would have done that type of damage to your chamber unless it was improperly treated at the factory when they cut the feed ramp.
Carl Taylor- Posts : 8
Join date : 2011-06-10
Age : 72
Re: Lead deposits in chamber of S&W Model 41
My guess is porosity in the metal before machining and went unnoticed. If it had been done by something mechanical after the barrel was made there would have been burrs raised and chambering almost impossible afterwards.
A porous piece of metal with porosity that just happens to be at the chamber.
Virgil
A porous piece of metal with porosity that just happens to be at the chamber.
Virgil
Virgil Kane- Posts : 574
Join date : 2011-06-10
Page 2 of 2 • 1, 2
Similar topics
» 41 Chamber Question
» lead in chamber, or the previous shot went foof, not bang
» Best way to clean the chamber in a Model 52
» Chamber polishing vs chamber reaming
» 52-2 dirty chamber
» lead in chamber, or the previous shot went foof, not bang
» Best way to clean the chamber in a Model 52
» Chamber polishing vs chamber reaming
» 52-2 dirty chamber
Page 2 of 2
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|