1911 9mm Barrel Fluting Question
+3
Jon Eulette
Olde Pilot
amlew
7 posters
Page 1 of 1
1911 9mm Barrel Fluting Question
Does anyone know if fluting a 9mm 1911 match barrel can affect its accuracy?
I'm considering having this done to lighten the pistols weight.
Thanks in advance.
I'm considering having this done to lighten the pistols weight.
Thanks in advance.
amlew- Posts : 6
Join date : 2015-04-05
Re: 1911 9mm Barrel Fluting Question
Reduction in weight will be so slight as to be inconsequential. 1911 barrel is thin anyway and don't believe any reputable machinist/gunsmith will do it.
Olde Pilot- Posts : 315
Join date : 2015-07-27
Location : Apopka Fl (Central Fl)
Re: 1911 9mm Barrel Fluting Question
Are you shooting with irons or optics? I’ve lightened slides under the optic rail to shed some weight. Cuts are hidden.
Jon
Jon
Jon Eulette- Posts : 4399
Join date : 2013-04-15
Location : Southern Kalifornia
Re: 1911 9mm Barrel Fluting Question
Jon Eulette wrote:Are you shooting with irons or optics? I’ve lightened slides under the optic rail to shed some weight. Cuts are hidden.
Jon
The 1911 will be a longslide with iron sights. Thanks for your input. The pistolsmith building it says he can flute the barrel. I'll probably have this done. I just wasn't sure if fluting can affect accuracy. My desire is to lighten the weight of the pistol without having it "look" lightened.
amlew- Posts : 6
Join date : 2015-04-05
Re: 1911 9mm Barrel Fluting Question
Not to be an ass, but why would you go with a heavier long slide if you knew weight could be an issue? You can have the slide internally lightened just like the old National Match 1911’s. I would go this route before fluting a barrel.
Jon
Jon
Jon Eulette- Posts : 4399
Join date : 2013-04-15
Location : Southern Kalifornia
Re: 1911 9mm Barrel Fluting Question
I have a CLARK LONG HEAVY SLIDE gun and don’t find the weight excessive at all. It handles, balances, and shoots very well.
Kurt
Kurt
kjanracing- Posts : 410
Join date : 2015-02-17
Location : Arvada, Colorado
Re: 1911 9mm Barrel Fluting Question
No offense taken on your question. I just like the looks of a longslide. I've owned a 9mm version before with a 2 piece guide rod, but I thought it was just a little heavy for me. For this next 9mm build, I wanted to explore what could be done to lighten it while still retaining the traditional"look". Unfortunately, the pistolsmith building it doesn't offer the National Match internal slide lightening you just mentioned. He can flute the barrel though.Jon Eulette wrote:Not to be an ass, but why would you go with a heavier long slide if you knew weight could be an issue? You can have the slide internally lightened just like the old National Match 1911’s. I would go this route before fluting a barrel.
Jon
As a side note, in the distant past, I once owned 45acp longslide that had a full length 2 piece guide rod and it's weight was to my liking. For this 9mm version, I figure if the barrel were fluted and I forgo a full length guide rod, I should be ok.
Jon, just wanted to mention I've always enjoyed reading your posts over the years. They've been very insightful. In fact I was hoping you would reply to this one.
Thank you
amlew- Posts : 6
Join date : 2015-04-05
Re: 1911 9mm Barrel Fluting Question
The builder can flute a 1911 barrel, but he cant do national match lightning??? Sounds strange to me... I use a ball end mill and simply plunge in and go back and forth... pretty simple...
10sandxs- Posts : 971
Join date : 2016-01-29
Re: 1911 9mm Barrel Fluting Question
Heavy slide with a light barrel sounds like the worst of both worlds to me.
I'd also be concerned if the smith is claiming he's going to reduce weight a noticeable amount by fluting a standard bushing barrel (different story on a bull barrel).
But, to each their own.
I'd also be concerned if the smith is claiming he's going to reduce weight a noticeable amount by fluting a standard bushing barrel (different story on a bull barrel).
But, to each their own.
mpolans- Posts : 606
Join date : 2016-05-27
Re: 1911 9mm Barrel Fluting Question
Just for fun. I whipped up a simple model of a fluted 1911 barrel. The flutes themselves actually. Using a .125 ball end mill, .05 deep for a .06 wall (based on a 45 barrel I have), and a flute length (3.4") for a 1" longer barrel, i get a weight reduction of .53 oz for 8 flutes.
WesG- Posts : 708
Join date : 2018-09-21
Location : Cedar Park, TX - N CA
Similar topics
» Question on barrel and bushing fit on 1911's
» Bushing barrel vs Bull barrel 1911
» Barrel fitting question
» S&W Model 17-5 Barrel Question
» Barrel Link Question
» Bushing barrel vs Bull barrel 1911
» Barrel fitting question
» S&W Model 17-5 Barrel Question
» Barrel Link Question
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|