Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
+17
troystaten
faraim
fc60
8eightring
WesG
straybrit
spursnguns
lyman1903
Oleg G
john bickar
PMcfall
zanemoseley
BE Mike
brassmaster
TAB
Wobbley
lanjo
21 posters
Page 1 of 2
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
Hi All,
I was wondering if you can recommend a bench top powder measure for pistol. Is there one that is accurate that wont break the bank. I like the Redding 10X pistol small rifle but it is $250 with stand.
Joe
I was wondering if you can recommend a bench top powder measure for pistol. Is there one that is accurate that wont break the bank. I like the Redding 10X pistol small rifle but it is $250 with stand.
Joe
lanjo- Posts : 103
Join date : 2015-02-22
Location : Richmond, VA
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
How much will break the bank?
Wobbley- Admin
- Posts : 4776
Join date : 2015-02-13
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
$200. I could do the Redding 10X Pistol Measure, but if there is something else out there which is just as good for less I would obviously go for that.
lanjo- Posts : 103
Join date : 2015-02-22
Location : Richmond, VA
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
Well for that price range I’d go with a Hornady or an RCBS with the small pistol drum. Then I’d get “micrometer” adjustments. The Hornady has separate metering stems you can purchase so you can set a few to favorite loads. Perhaps that is the way to go.
Wobbley- Admin
- Posts : 4776
Join date : 2015-02-13
Redding 3BR
A Redding 3BR at Brownells, it's even in stock. At some later date you can add a rifle rotor to cover larger loads. I use one and it just plain works nice. Way more accurate and repeatable than the RCBS I sold off. Record the micrometer setting for powder and grains, come back later with the same setting and powder and it is on the dot with minimal if any adjustment.
TAB
REDDING POWDER MEASURE 3BR/PISTOL
749-008-012WB
3BR Powder Measure w/Pistol Insert
Mfr Part: 03600
$199.99
TAB
REDDING POWDER MEASURE 3BR/PISTOL
749-008-012WB
3BR Powder Measure w/Pistol Insert
Mfr Part: 03600
$199.99
TAB- Posts : 51
Join date : 2015-01-20
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
You see it regularly posted on here: "buy once, cry once." For decades, I was an RCBS devoted user and I purchased the RCBS pistol rotor for my rifle powder measure and found that trying to get consistency with small powder charges was futile. It was all over the map, got under throws and over throws of powder charges. Purchased a Hornady Lock N Load powder measure with pistol metering powder charger---same result. Sold both and bought the Redding pistol measure and my powder charging issues were over. Checked every fifth throw on two electronic powder measures and powder throws were on the money. Consistent whether on the bench loading "match loads" or on my progressive loader. To echo another poster, set the Redding micrometer readings for your pet load or whatever small charge, record them, change the settings for another load or powder choice, go back to the pet load, set the micrometer meter to those settings and start throwing consistent charges! I've had my Redding for 10 years+/-, absolutely no issues. Bite the proverbial bullet and buy the Redding, you will not regret it.lanjo wrote:Hi All,
I was wondering if you can recommend a bench top powder measure for pistol. Is there one that is accurate that wont break the bank. I like the Redding 10X pistol small rifle but it is $250 with stand.
Joe
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
I'd go electronic, actually I already did, many years ago. I got the predecessor of the Lyman Gen6 Digital Powder Measure and it is still going strong. You get a powder measure and scale all in one.
BE Mike- Posts : 2564
Join date : 2011-07-29
Location : Indiana
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
I love my RCBS chargemaster but its more geared to feeding extruded rifle powders than ball powders. I tried using to to load some test loads for a pistol and had to go back to using a manual powder measure since it wasn't feeding well through the chargemaster.
zanemoseley- Posts : 2688
Join date : 2015-07-11
Location : Cookeville, TN
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
Although they are expensive, I would choose the Harrels measure. I have a couple that I use with benchrest rifles that I load on the line without a scale. I think if you attend a benchrest match, this brand measure will be the predominant measure in use. If you told me I couldn't use a Harrels, I would grab a Belding Mull.
Schuetzen / Pistol Measure (harrellsprec.com)
Phil
Schuetzen / Pistol Measure (harrellsprec.com)
Phil
PMcfall- Posts : 392
Join date : 2011-06-16
Location : St. Joseph, MO
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
I agree with BEMike, I already had the Redding pistol powder measure when I purchased a Hornady electronic powder measure and I got two in one: a very accurate powder measure and an electronic scale for about the same price as a Redding bench measure when you can catch them on sale at Midway or some other vendor. With the Hornady electronic powder measure you can consistently throw 3.8 grains of Bullseye powder or throw enough rifle powder to load a .458 Winchester. I see no negatives with the Hornady electronic powder measure, just positives. A buddy has a Lyman and he swears by it too. Also, it's worth listening to Zane as he is a very experienced individual. One day after going through the calibration protocols for the Hornady electronic powder measure, it would not calibrate. I boxed it up and shipped it off to Hornady asking them to recalibrate it. About ten days later UPS delivered what I believed to be my recalibrated powder measure. To my surprise it was a brand new Hornady electronic powder measure. Apparently, the corporate mindset is that it's cost effective to replace the item vs. a technician spending time repairing it.BE Mike wrote:I'd go electronic, actually I already did, many years ago. I got the predecessor of the Lyman Gen6 Digital Powder Measure and it is still going strong. You get a powder measure and scale all in one.
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
I've been pretty happy with the Frankford Arsenal IntelliDropper. I've used it for both rifle and pistol loads. Natchez just had it on sale; not sure if it's still going on.
john bickar- Posts : 2269
Join date : 2011-07-09
Age : 100
Location : Menlo Park, CA
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
Another vote for the Frankford Arsenal IntelliDropper - very consistent and easy to use.
Oleg G- Posts : 608
Join date : 2016-05-12
Location : North-Eastern PA
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
well hello neighbor (I'm in Chesterfield Va)
you can make a stand if you are handy with tools, if that will save you a few bucks
you can make a stand if you are handy with tools, if that will save you a few bucks
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
PMcfall wrote:Although they are expensive, I would choose the Harrels measure. I have a couple that I use with benchrest rifles that I load on the line without a scale. I think if you attend a benchrest match, this brand measure will be the predominant measure in use.
Hello,
I have two Harrell's. They are superb....accurate and repeatable. It's easy for me to say but the extra money will be well worth it. If not, buy a Redding.
Jim
spursnguns- Posts : 611
Join date : 2013-01-04
Age : 66
Location : Nampa, Idaho
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
According to their website they are only for 2g+. For .32 we really need around 1.6g. Of course that's a niche market :-)
straybrit- Posts : 386
Join date : 2012-09-05
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
I have a Harrell's Schuetzen measure as well. It works pretty well with larger charges, but small ones not so great. When you close it way down you get a very deep narrow cavity that doesn't fill consistantly.
I went back to my Little Dandy, and modified some of the 00 drums to get what I wanted. The Hornady would be a good option as well.
I have a couple of the larger Redding BR measures, and like them a lot. But I've never used one of the pistol size units.
I went back to my Little Dandy, and modified some of the 00 drums to get what I wanted. The Hornady would be a good option as well.
I have a couple of the larger Redding BR measures, and like them a lot. But I've never used one of the pistol size units.
WesG- Posts : 710
Join date : 2018-09-21
Location : Cedar Park, TX - N CA
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
I like to use the Lyman 55 powder measure when I am not loading with a progressive press.
Don't leave Bullseye powder in the hopper though. Ask me how I know this.
https://www.ebay.com/itm/224603728935?hash=item344b6cec27:g:UHYAAOSwDl5hOo0h
Don't leave Bullseye powder in the hopper though. Ask me how I know this.
https://www.ebay.com/itm/224603728935?hash=item344b6cec27:g:UHYAAOSwDl5hOo0h
Last edited by 8eightring on 9/15/2021, 3:41 pm; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : added a link)
8eightring- Posts : 192
Join date : 2011-06-17
Location : Ohio
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
Greetings,
A friend gifted me a Redding 10X Pistol Measure.
10X Measure
It has a rather small diameter powder cavity and dispenses "light" loads quite well. I mean in the range of 1.2-2.0 grains of Bullseye, N310, WST, TiteWAD, etc.
It has a micrometer adjustment so you can write down the final setting for future use.
I do not trust the electronic scales for small charges.
Cheers,
David
A friend gifted me a Redding 10X Pistol Measure.
10X Measure
It has a rather small diameter powder cavity and dispenses "light" loads quite well. I mean in the range of 1.2-2.0 grains of Bullseye, N310, WST, TiteWAD, etc.
It has a micrometer adjustment so you can write down the final setting for future use.
I do not trust the electronic scales for small charges.
Cheers,
David
fc60- Posts : 1451
Join date : 2011-06-11
Location : South Prairie, WA 98385
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
That 10X looks interesting - does anyone know of an adapter/frame that would allow it to be fitted to progressive press?
straybrit- Posts : 386
Join date : 2012-09-05
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
I'm not sure what powder you are planning on using, but if it is an older, flake type I'd suggest a Lyman 55. Many of the older flake powders are very irregular in shape, Unique, Red Dot and Bullseye come to mind. For those I've had more uniform throws with the odd rectangular cavity on the Lyman drum. If you are using one of the newer, fine grained powders like Tightgroup, AA#2, or even WST then buy a Redding. The Redding micrometer adjustment is repeatable, something the slides on the Lyman aren't. Keep an eye on eBay, I bought a Lyman 55 for under $50 and a Redding for under $100 over the last year and a half.
faraim- Posts : 99
Join date : 2020-06-10
8eightring likes this post
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
I have an RCBS Little dandy, since I use a single stage press I am not rushing so I set all the cartridges in blocks and charge them one after the other holding the charger in my hand. I can then go and run a flash light over the block and make sure I got them all and did not double charge any cases. The Little dandy is consistent but less flexible since it uses interchangeable rotors to determine the amount of powder dispensed. They work well.
troystaten- Posts : 823
Join date : 2012-04-19
faraim likes this post
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
I use a Redding measure for 32s; l stuffed it into the top of a Lee powder through die. Works perfect but I have to remember to throw the lever
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
https://www.midwayusa.com/product/101273579/
Measure and pistol rotor 72.22 43.99
I just got this and the case activating linkage to use on top of the Dillon.
Measure and pistol rotor 72.22 43.99
I just got this and the case activating linkage to use on top of the Dillon.
Jack H- Posts : 2693
Join date : 2011-06-10
Age : 75
Location : Oregon
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
I use a Lee PPM with an aquarium pump zip-tied to the powder hopper. It's cheap, and from an actual test data standpoint, did just as well as a Redding, Hornady, and Harrels (the other three I tested and returned), on small charges of flake powder. I also run two Chargemasters with a choker tube installed (that you can get on eBay), and have reprogrammed them both (basically slowing them down). They don't over-throw small charges any more (up to 25 gr for .223 rifle), which was a big problem with that system. Their limitation is that the tare weight tends to drift +/- 0.1 gr over time while you are loading, even after warming up. I'm not sure what causes this. I might try a power conditioner, but they can be expensive.
tovaert- Posts : 448
Join date : 2018-11-28
Re: Bench Top Powder Measure - Pistol
So - disappearing down the youtube rabbit hole I found this ...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=arz_AM8K8B8
Where there's a comparison between the Dillon Extra Small powder bar, the Arredondo powder bar and an RCBS rotary
There's a couple of 'follow-on' videos as well. I can say this guy takes his press prep seriously. I have no idea how effective it is - but he's certainly very focused.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=arz_AM8K8B8
Where there's a comparison between the Dillon Extra Small powder bar, the Arredondo powder bar and an RCBS rotary
There's a couple of 'follow-on' videos as well. I can say this guy takes his press prep seriously. I have no idea how effective it is - but he's certainly very focused.
straybrit- Posts : 386
Join date : 2012-09-05
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
Similar topics
» Lee Auto-Drum Powder Measure and CFE Pistol powder metering
» Leaving powder in the powder measure
» Powder Measure
» Powder Measure
» Powder measure question
» Leaving powder in the powder measure
» Powder Measure
» Powder Measure
» Powder measure question
Page 1 of 2
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|