Conversion magazines
4 posters
Page 1 of 1
Conversion magazines
I Don't know about the current Marvels.
My early Marvel was horribly unreliable-it was the magazines. - I tried a Kimber conversion magazine.-Much better, but not perfect (staggered rounds in the mag didn't rise reliably). - Tried AA conversion magazines-100% reliable- & didn't actuate the slide stop (I heard some do). - The AA mags were a little tight in one lower; a flat file easily fixed that. -I like the AA magazines - use them for the Marvel and AA.
A test:
Taking all safety precautions, I took my best Marvel steel magazine, loaded 5 rounds and quickly cycled them thru the pistol-without firing them-ejected rounds falling onto carpet. - Repeated with Kimber magazine. - Repeated with AA magazine. - all w/ same Marvel/lower.
Results - grades:
Marvel steel mag: "F" The rounds/bullets were very beat up-nicks lead scraped off - looked terrible-. Sold 3 for $25.
Kimber magazine: "C"- almost couldn't tell the cycled rounds from new ones. -But there was the occasional problem of rounds hanging up in the mag.
AA magazine: "B+" - 100% reliable - some rounds very slightly dinged from chambering-not bad at all. -- -had to file down to fall free from 1 lower.
2¢-YMMV --- -Russ
My early Marvel was horribly unreliable-it was the magazines. - I tried a Kimber conversion magazine.-Much better, but not perfect (staggered rounds in the mag didn't rise reliably). - Tried AA conversion magazines-100% reliable- & didn't actuate the slide stop (I heard some do). - The AA mags were a little tight in one lower; a flat file easily fixed that. -I like the AA magazines - use them for the Marvel and AA.
A test:
Taking all safety precautions, I took my best Marvel steel magazine, loaded 5 rounds and quickly cycled them thru the pistol-without firing them-ejected rounds falling onto carpet. - Repeated with Kimber magazine. - Repeated with AA magazine. - all w/ same Marvel/lower.
Results - grades:
Marvel steel mag: "F" The rounds/bullets were very beat up-nicks lead scraped off - looked terrible-. Sold 3 for $25.
Kimber magazine: "C"- almost couldn't tell the cycled rounds from new ones. -But there was the occasional problem of rounds hanging up in the mag.
AA magazine: "B+" - 100% reliable - some rounds very slightly dinged from chambering-not bad at all. -- -had to file down to fall free from 1 lower.
2¢-YMMV --- -Russ
Russ OR- Posts : 269
Join date : 2011-06-10
Location : Oregon City, OR
Re: Conversion magazines
Pro Mags (plastic) A+ never had one fail.
- Dave
- Dave
dronning- Posts : 2581
Join date : 2013-03-20
Age : 71
Location : Lakeville, MN
Re: Conversion magazines
Never had any issues with any of the plastic magazines that came with my Nelson. I vaguely remember reading some article or post about why plastic mags are a better choice for 22LR than the steel ones, but can't remember any details.
Re: Conversion magazines
2 year old lock back Marvel on OLD Colt frame...I never had any issues until the compensator was almost completely plugged.
I have 1 Marvel, 4 Kimber plastic, & 6 GSG aluminum. They all work fine FOR ME.
I have 1 Marvel, 4 Kimber plastic, & 6 GSG aluminum. They all work fine FOR ME.
STEVE SAMELAK- Posts : 958
Join date : 2011-06-10
Similar topics
» conversion magazines
» 22lr conversion magazines
» Nelson Conversion Kit Magazines
» Jagemann 22 conversion magazines
» ProMag magazines for Nelson Conversion
» 22lr conversion magazines
» Nelson Conversion Kit Magazines
» Jagemann 22 conversion magazines
» ProMag magazines for Nelson Conversion
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum