Tom Menck ironing tool alternatives
+2
jglenn21
SW-52
6 posters
Page 1 of 1
Tom Menck ironing tool alternatives
i found this curious tool on internet and is discontinued. what alternatives for this tool for repair a little strike on my HS barrel chamber. https://www.brownells.com/gunsmith-tools-supplies/handgun-tools/chamber-tools/22-chamber-ironing-tool-prod8869.aspx
SW-52- Posts : 805
Join date : 2015-07-20
Age : 40
Re: Tom Menck ironing tool alternatives
if they really are discontinued that's a bummer.. that tool has been around for years and works...
I do remember many "old" time smiths would use a long punch inserted into the chamber to peen the pin strike back in place.. the taper does the work.
Also Brownells had an article years ago in either Gunsmith Kinks or their Newsletter many years back about using a #1 drill bit(.228 in Dia.) then cutting a flat in the base a bit shorter than chamber length.. after cutting it you'd roll the edge a bit to smooth them out.. inserting the tool with the flat against the peened area then twisting it would swag the are back the same as the Merik tool.. Today I'd use a pin gauge for that purpose if I had to make one..
I'd suggest searching your local Smiths for one that has the Merik tool
I do remember many "old" time smiths would use a long punch inserted into the chamber to peen the pin strike back in place.. the taper does the work.
Also Brownells had an article years ago in either Gunsmith Kinks or their Newsletter many years back about using a #1 drill bit(.228 in Dia.) then cutting a flat in the base a bit shorter than chamber length.. after cutting it you'd roll the edge a bit to smooth them out.. inserting the tool with the flat against the peened area then twisting it would swag the are back the same as the Merik tool.. Today I'd use a pin gauge for that purpose if I had to make one..
I'd suggest searching your local Smiths for one that has the Merik tool
jglenn21- Posts : 2620
Join date : 2015-04-07
Age : 76
Location : monroe , ga
Re: Tom Menck ironing tool alternatives
thanks.jglenn21 wrote:if they really are discontinued that's a bummer.. that tool has been around for years and works...
I do remember many "old" time smiths would use a long punch inserted into the chamber to peen the pin strike back in place.. the taper does the work.
Also Brownells had an article years ago in either Gunsmith Kinks or their Newsletter many years back about using a #1 drill bit(.228 in Dia.) then cutting a flat in the base a bit shorter than chamber length.. after cutting it you'd roll the edge a bit to smooth them out.. inserting the tool with the flat against the peened area then twisting it would swag the are back the same as the Merik tool.. Today I'd use a pin gauge for that purpose if I had to make one..
I'd suggest searching your local Smiths for one that has the Merik tool
SW-52- Posts : 805
Join date : 2015-07-20
Age : 40
Re: Tom Menck ironing tool alternatives
jglenn21 wrote:if they really are discontinued that's a bummer.. that tool has been around for years and works...
I do remember many "old" time smiths would use a long punch inserted into the chamber to peen the pin strike back in place.. the taper does the work.
Also Brownells had an article years ago in either Gunsmith Kinks or their Newsletter many years back about using a #1 drill bit(.228 in Dia.) then cutting a flat in the base a bit shorter than chamber length.. after cutting it you'd roll the edge a bit to smooth them out.. inserting the tool with the flat against the peened area then twisting it would swag the are back the same as the Merik tool.. Today I'd use a pin gauge for that purpose if I had to make one..
I'd suggest searching your local Smiths for one that has the Merik tool
I have used the long punch method years ago to fix a couple of High Standard HD's , worked very well, just go slow and easy
Re: Tom Menck ironing tool alternatives
Would this kind of "fix" affect the original accuracy at all?
Saladman- Posts : 115
Join date : 2016-01-13
Re: Tom Menck ironing tool alternatives
Shouldn't effect it. It's at rear of chamber. Basically just removing the deformation from the firing pin strike on the edge of the chamber. You'd be surprised at how many RF pistols have this problem.
Jon
Jon
Jon Eulette- Posts : 4399
Join date : 2013-04-15
Location : Southern Kalifornia
Re: Tom Menck ironing tool alternatives
Some get the extractor groove kinked in too.
I saw a tool like the Menck made from a long taper punch. Cut off at the right spot, flatted and polished. The shank was hex so a box wrench turned it easy. I have my own Menck. Works great. On a HS Olympic, the soft aluminum slide let the firing pin forward (extractor too) and made a crater dimple in the barrel. I straightened it out and it shot fine.
On the early Marvel I had the extractor grove kept bending in. I believe they fixed that with a straight cut in the barrel and reshape the extractor head. Is this so?
I saw a tool like the Menck made from a long taper punch. Cut off at the right spot, flatted and polished. The shank was hex so a box wrench turned it easy. I have my own Menck. Works great. On a HS Olympic, the soft aluminum slide let the firing pin forward (extractor too) and made a crater dimple in the barrel. I straightened it out and it shot fine.
On the early Marvel I had the extractor grove kept bending in. I believe they fixed that with a straight cut in the barrel and reshape the extractor head. Is this so?
Jack H- Posts : 2699
Join date : 2011-06-10
Age : 75
Location : Oregon
Similar topics
» Chamber Ironing Swage tool
» Ultradot Alternatives?
» Alternatives to a spotting scope
» 1911 Alternatives (non revolver)
» AimPoint 9000 - Mounting Rings - Alternatives
» Ultradot Alternatives?
» Alternatives to a spotting scope
» 1911 Alternatives (non revolver)
» AimPoint 9000 - Mounting Rings - Alternatives
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum