INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
+10
Chris Miceli
cdrt
boatbum101
teg2658
Multiracer
PhotoEscape
dronning
Wobbley
rreid
orpheoet
14 posters
Page 1 of 1
INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
Im curious what others have experienced when putting a dot on a 38 wadcutter 1911. Currently using 2.7 WST without the dot. I'm assuming I'll have to go up? 7 Lb recoils spring and 100% reliable without dot.
orpheoet- Posts : 1054
Join date : 2014-07-29
Age : 56
Location : Berea, Oh
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
If you put a frame mount on it, you won't have to change your load.
rreid- Posts : 562
Join date : 2012-02-06
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
At 2.7 WST, you’re close to the maximum now. You’d probably have to change powders. Bullseye would be about the same. Might have to go to the Green Dot class of powders or even as slow as 231. Try 2.8 WST or Bullseye first. This of course depends on the dot you have.
LenV has a dot on his 52 and maybe he can shed some further light.
LenV has a dot on his 52 and maybe he can shed some further light.
Wobbley- Admin
- Posts : 4773
Join date : 2015-02-13
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
You didn't say if you are shooting HBWC or not. You DO NOT want to go too hot of a load with a HBWC because there is a risk of the base separating and you may not even know it, which is probably the #1 reason people are looking for barrel replacements for the 52.
- Dave
- Dave
dronning- Posts : 2581
Join date : 2013-03-20
Age : 70
Location : Lakeville, MN
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
I shoot 2.8gr BE under Remington 148gr out of M52-2 equipped with Ultradot. Same works fine and very accurate in second M52-2 without dot and Colt MIII Midrange.
AP
AP
PhotoEscape- Admin
- Posts : 1533
Join date : 2018-05-15
Location : Northern Illinois, USA
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
He is asking about a 1911 chambered in 38 spcl. NOT a 52-2
Multiracer- Posts : 990
Join date : 2017-03-15
Location : North Ohio
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
I had a Giles 38 Spec 1911 and 2.8 of bullseye cycled it flawless, with 2.7 I had some issues with cycling. The dot was a Aimpoint 3000, slide mount.
Tom Ginovsky
Tom Ginovsky
teg2658- Posts : 263
Join date : 2014-05-22
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
Dave,
Please correct me if I'm wrong, as this is more conceptual than the answer to particular question in this thread. With that.... I believe, that powder charges of the same powder using same weight/type or just same weight projectiles in similar cartridges (i.e. 38 Special - 38 SWC - 357M, or 9mm/38S) would be close to identical. Very minor adjustments in charge weight needed to accommodate the difference in pressure developed based on particular cartridge dimensions, and a little bit more based on type of projectile (i.e. SWC versus Full WC, but both of the same material i.e. lead or plated). I believe, that such difference is about a tenth. So given same platform is used (i.e. 1911 - i.e. MIII Midrange or Giles 38 Special), with close specs (recoil / main spring), then data from one can be adopted for another. Right? Tom G's post seam confirms such.
AP
Please correct me if I'm wrong, as this is more conceptual than the answer to particular question in this thread. With that.... I believe, that powder charges of the same powder using same weight/type or just same weight projectiles in similar cartridges (i.e. 38 Special - 38 SWC - 357M, or 9mm/38S) would be close to identical. Very minor adjustments in charge weight needed to accommodate the difference in pressure developed based on particular cartridge dimensions, and a little bit more based on type of projectile (i.e. SWC versus Full WC, but both of the same material i.e. lead or plated). I believe, that such difference is about a tenth. So given same platform is used (i.e. 1911 - i.e. MIII Midrange or Giles 38 Special), with close specs (recoil / main spring), then data from one can be adopted for another. Right? Tom G's post seam confirms such.
AP
PhotoEscape- Admin
- Posts : 1533
Join date : 2018-05-15
Location : Northern Illinois, USA
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
It was a caution on using HBWCs with too much powder, in other words go slow. 1911s chambered in 38 Special use WC loads, some use DEWC with good results. Same issue can happen with ANY gun revolver or semi-auto when using a HBWC. I just brought up the 52 because I know of at least 4 barrels that have been bulged due to the base of a HBWC separating and then being hit by the next round. Sometimes the shooter doesn't even notice it but it still will bulge the barrel slightly.Multiracer wrote:He is asking about a 1911 chambered in 38 spcl. NOT a 52-2
- Dave
dronning- Posts : 2581
Join date : 2013-03-20
Age : 70
Location : Lakeville, MN
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
This is from my experience with a S&W 52-2 with a slide mounted 1" UD shooting HBWC loads . 2.9 WST is as hot as I'd shoot , Bullseye I wouldn't exceed that either . 3.2 W231 gave me best accuracy / function , close second was 3.6 VVn-340 . All with either Rem or Zero 148 HBWC , 7lb recoil spring . Perhaps a lighter mainspring & / or increased radius on FPS , but I'd get advise from Jon E. or KC before I went that route . IIRC some of the Colts had hollowed out firing pin blocks in the slides like the early NM / GC's .
boatbum101- Posts : 46
Join date : 2013-04-04
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
Guess I'll jump in on this. I have a Clark Heavy Slide .38 Special with the full length Bo-Mar tuner rib (5 inch barrel). It works just fine with 2.7 BE, a 7 pound recoil spring and either Remington or Hornady HBWC's. If I go any hotter, the group opens up and I get leading.
I weighed a similar Bo-Mar rib and it came out to be the same weight as Marvel's dot rib for the 1911, which means, if I mounted the Marvel rib and a dot, the slide and dot would weigh a significant amount more than it does with just the Bo-Mar rib.
The only way I could get the mount and dot to work, would be to increase the powder charge since a 7 pound spring is about as light has you can go, and that would lead to less accuracy and leading in the barrel.
So bottom line, I left it alone, since I can still shoot Expert scores with it and I saw no reason to screw up a shooter.
Also, the original poster said he is using 2.7 WST. 2.7 WST and 2.7 BE are not the same thing, so please do not misinterpret what I said above about bullets and powder charges for my particular pistol.
I weighed a similar Bo-Mar rib and it came out to be the same weight as Marvel's dot rib for the 1911, which means, if I mounted the Marvel rib and a dot, the slide and dot would weigh a significant amount more than it does with just the Bo-Mar rib.
The only way I could get the mount and dot to work, would be to increase the powder charge since a 7 pound spring is about as light has you can go, and that would lead to less accuracy and leading in the barrel.
So bottom line, I left it alone, since I can still shoot Expert scores with it and I saw no reason to screw up a shooter.
Also, the original poster said he is using 2.7 WST. 2.7 WST and 2.7 BE are not the same thing, so please do not misinterpret what I said above about bullets and powder charges for my particular pistol.
cdrt- Posts : 842
Join date : 2016-04-12
Location : Amarillo, Texas
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
Yes hollow base wadcutters. I have Zero, Star, and Remington. The gun in question is suspected to be an MTU conversion as it has a 6" S&W barrel that I'm told was used for them. Whoever built it built it right, radiused hammer face, hand stippled front strap, set screw for the set screw in the trigger(I've heard that was a Clark signature mod). I shot a 97 slow fire with it a few years ago indoors with irons so I'm really looking forward to how it does with a dot.
orpheoet- Posts : 1054
Join date : 2014-07-29
Age : 56
Location : Berea, Oh
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
put a sams frame mount on it.
Chris Miceli- Posts : 2715
Join date : 2015-10-27
Location : Northern Virginia
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
I have a couple or three of the S&W barrels.. one 45 and two 38 spl.. one is going into a spl I'm building(been building for a while).. They were originally made for the MTU but smiths like Clark had access to them too.. the barrels were all made in 6" and then cut off from there if needed.
several of my old clarks had the steel trigger with a set screw for the stop screw.
what you use for a dot will matter as the weight varies quite a bit
several of my old clarks had the steel trigger with a set screw for the stop screw.
what you use for a dot will matter as the weight varies quite a bit
jglenn21- Posts : 2618
Join date : 2015-04-07
Age : 76
Location : monroe , ga
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
I have a bunch of 30mm Ultradots. better options?jglenn21 wrote:I have a couple or three of the S&W barrels.. one 45 and two 38 spl.. one is going into a spl I'm building(been building for a while).. They were originally made for the MTU but smiths like Clark had access to them too.. the barrels were all made in 6" and then cut off from there if needed.
several of my old clarks had the steel trigger with a set screw for the stop screw.
what you use for a dot will matter as the weight varies quite a bit
orpheoet- Posts : 1054
Join date : 2014-07-29
Age : 56
Location : Berea, Oh
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
the small aimpoint H1 style is light (3oz).. the base 30mm UD is 4.1 oz. the 1" UD is 3.9 oz.
you also can take some weight out of your dot rail, underneath..
start with what you have an see how it goes. 2.8 WST is not a bad option.
you also can take some weight out of your dot rail, underneath..
start with what you have an see how it goes. 2.8 WST is not a bad option.
jglenn21- Posts : 2618
Join date : 2015-04-07
Age : 76
Location : monroe , ga
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
My several 38 1911’s will all function (5” & 6”) with Aimpoint Micro mounted to Bomar mini-rib with 2.7 gr BE and 2.8 gr WST. I have ran UD in the past with no issues, but again from the mini-rib. I have rebuilt Clark heavy slide long slides with UD mounted with 2.8 gr BE and no issues.
I’d pick the load I wanted to shoot then adjust spring to the load.
Jon
I’d pick the load I wanted to shoot then adjust spring to the load.
Jon
Jon Eulette- Posts : 4399
Join date : 2013-04-15
Location : Southern Kalifornia
Jon Eulette- Posts : 4399
Join date : 2013-04-15
Location : Southern Kalifornia
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
Hello Jon,
You're a great pistol smith. As a photographer....not so much.
Jim
You're a great pistol smith. As a photographer....not so much.
Jim
spursnguns- Posts : 611
Join date : 2013-01-04
Age : 66
Location : Nampa, Idaho
dronning- Posts : 2581
Join date : 2013-03-20
Age : 70
Location : Lakeville, MN
LenV- Posts : 4758
Join date : 2014-01-24
Age : 74
Location : Oregon
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
Ha haspursnguns wrote:Hello Jon,
You're a great pistol smith. As a photographer....not so much.
Jim
Jon Eulette- Posts : 4399
Join date : 2013-04-15
Location : Southern Kalifornia
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
I'm having a RRA rail put on it. probably not the lightest option. I think I see an Aimpoint in my future....
orpheoet- Posts : 1054
Join date : 2014-07-29
Age : 56
Location : Berea, Oh
Re: INCREASED CHARGE FOR .38 WITH DOT
spursnguns wrote:Hello Jon,
You're a great pistol smith. As a photographer....not so much.
Jim
Multiracer- Posts : 990
Join date : 2017-03-15
Location : North Ohio
Similar topics
» What’s your WST charge in your 45?
» bullet and pwd charge for 9 mm
» wrong powder charge
» Purpose of Hard Cast Hollow Base Wadcutters?
» WC seating depth vs. charge
» bullet and pwd charge for 9 mm
» wrong powder charge
» Purpose of Hard Cast Hollow Base Wadcutters?
» WC seating depth vs. charge
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|