38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
+22
Redpen
Colt711
randy86314
Chris Miceli
Bob Fleming
Allgoodhits
Keithcrc
rbwillnj
Fritz Ficke
rvlvrlvr
dronning
tenx9
hunter3705
james r chapman
davekp
Jack H
Jerry Keefer
Dave C.
Virgil Kane
SMBeyer
BE Mike
inthebeech
26 posters
Page 2 of 2
Page 2 of 2 • 1, 2
38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
First topic message reminder :
Does it make sense that my 148 grain Lyman 358495 target bullet moving at 775 f/s, which groups off of bags at 25 yards in to less than one and a half inches, would become so unstable at 50 yards to open up to 6-8 inches?
It's my fault for not practicing much at fifty yards and discovering this earlier, but I really don't need this problem three weeks before my first BE match. I don't want to have to be doing 'load development' any more this season, but I'm glad to have discovered this now.
Does it make sense that my 148 grain Lyman 358495 target bullet moving at 775 f/s, which groups off of bags at 25 yards in to less than one and a half inches, would become so unstable at 50 yards to open up to 6-8 inches?
It's my fault for not practicing much at fifty yards and discovering this earlier, but I really don't need this problem three weeks before my first BE match. I don't want to have to be doing 'load development' any more this season, but I'm glad to have discovered this now.
inthebeech- Posts : 657
Join date : 2012-03-17
Age : 59
Location : Harleysville, Pennsylvania
Re: 38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
I've tried all manner of 148gr swaged bullets and indeed 50yd accuracy is lacking. I've got 2000 Rem 148's from Precison Reloading and I am hoping for the best. Never tried them. I'm not going to push the bullets so fast that it equals the recoil of my .45. No point. I'm now trying W231 and then might resort to Power Pistol, which might have some merit. I tried 4.0gr of W231 with a Berrys 125 and the results might indicate that I indeed go to a lighter charge. 4.2 to 4.6 was absolutely horrible. The 4.0 load had 2 three shot clusters about 3 1/2" apart. Years ago I gave up and just used my .45. Now because of bad shoulders and elbows, trying again
tenx9- Posts : 52
Join date : 2012-12-03
Re: 38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
Model 52-2 .38 special Remington 148 HBWC loaded with 2.4-2.5 of Clays very accurate at 50yds. If you push the HBWC too fast the skirts blow out and accuracy - well there is none at that point.
Last edited by dronning on 12/10/2013, 3:36 am; edited 1 time in total
dronning- Posts : 2581
Join date : 2013-03-20
Age : 71
Location : Lakeville, MN
Re: 38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
inthebeech - you mention using Speer HBWC bullets before trying the Remington HBWCs. Were the Speers the 'new' ones with that hard, slippery-feeling coating/lube on them? If they were, I'd wonder if that wasn't the reason for the poor grouping.
My own anecdotes: I tried the Speer HBWC over 3.1gr W231 out of a 6" S&W Model 686-5 revolver with the 'new' EDM-cut rifling in the barrel, and found it couldn't group worth a darn. My shooting buddies all tried the Speer 98gr .32 HBWC bullets in thei Hammerli 280 pistols and they were also experiencing inconsistencies (and even keyholing). When we all switched to something else (I went with those Remington 148gr HBWCs in my wheelgun; they went with Magnus Cast 98gr WCs for their pistols), acceptable groupings (with no keyholes or uncalled fliers) returned.
My own anecdotes: I tried the Speer HBWC over 3.1gr W231 out of a 6" S&W Model 686-5 revolver with the 'new' EDM-cut rifling in the barrel, and found it couldn't group worth a darn. My shooting buddies all tried the Speer 98gr .32 HBWC bullets in thei Hammerli 280 pistols and they were also experiencing inconsistencies (and even keyholing). When we all switched to something else (I went with those Remington 148gr HBWCs in my wheelgun; they went with Magnus Cast 98gr WCs for their pistols), acceptable groupings (with no keyholes or uncalled fliers) returned.
Last edited by rvlvrlvr on 11/30/2013, 9:07 pm; edited 1 time in total
rvlvrlvr- Posts : 193
Join date : 2011-06-10
Location : Northern Virginia
GerhardG likes this post
Re: 38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
One of the challenges with shooting the slow .38 wc is you have to have really good follow through to not "key hole" even with the best ammunition.
Fritz Ficke- Posts : 13
Join date : 2013-11-20
Age : 62
Location : Tucson AZ.
Re: 38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
Ok, not that all of this advice was not useful; in fact there are some great tips.
But I have to come clean or perhaps this final bit of information will cause fellow shooters to keep an open mind when encountering similar problems.
Somewhere in the early history of this revolver, I lodged a bullet about an inch from the muzzle and, you guessed it, pushed it out without even knowing it and bulged the barrel. Becaue I did not notice it, the search began for the cause of sudden inaccuracy, which led to the start of this thread. I have since had a great revolversmith replace the barrel and guess what? My original load is once again shooting ragged holes at 25 yds with very little effort.
We never stop learning.
But I have to come clean or perhaps this final bit of information will cause fellow shooters to keep an open mind when encountering similar problems.
Somewhere in the early history of this revolver, I lodged a bullet about an inch from the muzzle and, you guessed it, pushed it out without even knowing it and bulged the barrel. Becaue I did not notice it, the search began for the cause of sudden inaccuracy, which led to the start of this thread. I have since had a great revolversmith replace the barrel and guess what? My original load is once again shooting ragged holes at 25 yds with very little effort.
We never stop learning.
inthebeech- Posts : 657
Join date : 2012-03-17
Age : 59
Location : Harleysville, Pennsylvania
Slamfire likes this post
Couldn't Resist.
50 Yard target, Ransom Rest, Star Reloader of course.
In case you can't read the data on the target, 2.7 grains of 700X, Remington 148 Grain HBWC
Winchester SPP and I think it was Federal Brass, but it might have been Winchester. I use both but I don't mix.
At an average velocity of 793 fps, that's about the same speed as my 45 wad loads.
In case you can't read the data on the target, 2.7 grains of 700X, Remington 148 Grain HBWC
Winchester SPP and I think it was Federal Brass, but it might have been Winchester. I use both but I don't mix.
At an average velocity of 793 fps, that's about the same speed as my 45 wad loads.
- Attachments
.38 loadings
Good luck in your quest. In my experience .38s are fickle. When you do find a load they aren't very forgiving if you are not doing your part. 2.8 or 2.7 of Bullseye behind a HBWC is usually an ok load and leave some lead showing.
Keithcrc- Posts : 43
Join date : 2017-08-19
Re: 38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
A lot of good info has been provided by many. My thoughts are these:
I have never attended a pistol match where the shooting was done by Ransom Rests. Tailoring the ultimate load is useless, if you don't shoot that load well out of your gun, from your hand(s) during the allotted time for the strings. Instead of best accuracy, I look for acceptable accuracy range given a shooting distance requirement. From there, I try to determine if there is a load, a bullet, a powder combination, that permits "me" not my Ransom rest, to perform the best. Sometimes, it may not be the most accurate load.
I have some guns that have a slight edge on accuracy, and others which for whatever reason the trigger feels better, or I shoot it better. My preference for shooting a match is the gun with the "better" trigger "to me" as long as the accuracy is within that acceptable range. It doesn't matter how accurate your load is, or how accurate your gun is, if off hand, you shoot too many bad shots with it because of the trigger, grips, sights or whatever else. The Champion is often not determined by the best shots on the target, but by the fewest number of poor shots on the target.
WC velocities: Let me just say there are a lot of folks who shoot .38 spl 148 gr WC in NRA Action Pistol where we have a power factor floor. To reach that floor the bullets need to chrono at 810+fps. Most will load with a cushion 4-5%, so they run 840+ fps. ZERO, SPEER and "sometimes" Hornady HBWC will shoot 2" or less at these velocities, and many who run cast DEWC may go to 870-890 fps. The accuracy standard is 2" maximum at 50 yds. The point being, that 2" of less 50 yd groups are obtainable with 148 gr WC's from the high 600 fps to almost 900 fps. Most HBWC prefer the lower speed range, some DEWC or BNWC actually prefer the higher end. Bayou Bullet 138 gr BNWC run best around 900+/- fps. So sweet spot is one thing, acceptable accuracy range is yet another.
I have never attended a pistol match where the shooting was done by Ransom Rests. Tailoring the ultimate load is useless, if you don't shoot that load well out of your gun, from your hand(s) during the allotted time for the strings. Instead of best accuracy, I look for acceptable accuracy range given a shooting distance requirement. From there, I try to determine if there is a load, a bullet, a powder combination, that permits "me" not my Ransom rest, to perform the best. Sometimes, it may not be the most accurate load.
I have some guns that have a slight edge on accuracy, and others which for whatever reason the trigger feels better, or I shoot it better. My preference for shooting a match is the gun with the "better" trigger "to me" as long as the accuracy is within that acceptable range. It doesn't matter how accurate your load is, or how accurate your gun is, if off hand, you shoot too many bad shots with it because of the trigger, grips, sights or whatever else. The Champion is often not determined by the best shots on the target, but by the fewest number of poor shots on the target.
WC velocities: Let me just say there are a lot of folks who shoot .38 spl 148 gr WC in NRA Action Pistol where we have a power factor floor. To reach that floor the bullets need to chrono at 810+fps. Most will load with a cushion 4-5%, so they run 840+ fps. ZERO, SPEER and "sometimes" Hornady HBWC will shoot 2" or less at these velocities, and many who run cast DEWC may go to 870-890 fps. The accuracy standard is 2" maximum at 50 yds. The point being, that 2" of less 50 yd groups are obtainable with 148 gr WC's from the high 600 fps to almost 900 fps. Most HBWC prefer the lower speed range, some DEWC or BNWC actually prefer the higher end. Bayou Bullet 138 gr BNWC run best around 900+/- fps. So sweet spot is one thing, acceptable accuracy range is yet another.
Allgoodhits- Posts : 901
Join date : 2017-09-17
Location : Southport, NC
Re: 38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
I generally go with the loads H.M shooters posting high 90's SF and 100- hi x tf and rf,
Good enough for me not to reinvent the octagon wheel,
Good enough for me not to reinvent the octagon wheel,
james r chapman- Admin
- Posts : 6372
Join date : 2012-02-01
Age : 75
Location : HELL, Michigan
Re: 38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
It is possible to spin the wadcutter faster and get a little extra range before stability problems. Colt barrels have a faster twist. The real problem is that the wadcutter has serious aerodynamic problems. When I tried semi-wadcutters suddenly the problem went away and the S&W 14 became fun to shoot at the 200 yard rifle gongs.
I have tried shorter wadcutters and shot plenty of wadcutters in 45 colt, 45ACP, 45 auto rim, 44 mag and special, 357 and the 38. None were worth a dang beyond 100 yards. Most were not stable at 50 yards showing a little extra on one side of the holes in the target. All of them loved Keith designs at astounding long ranges.
My cure for the double ended and hollow base wad cutters in 38 special at 50 yards is the semi-wadcutter.
I have tried shorter wadcutters and shot plenty of wadcutters in 45 colt, 45ACP, 45 auto rim, 44 mag and special, 357 and the 38. None were worth a dang beyond 100 yards. Most were not stable at 50 yards showing a little extra on one side of the holes in the target. All of them loved Keith designs at astounding long ranges.
My cure for the double ended and hollow base wad cutters in 38 special at 50 yards is the semi-wadcutter.
Bob Fleming- Posts : 49
Join date : 2012-04-20
Location : Texas, Hunt county
Brent375hh likes this post
Re: 38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
run them out of a 10 or 12" twist....
james r chapman- Admin
- Posts : 6372
Join date : 2012-02-01
Age : 75
Location : HELL, Michigan
Re: 38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
Ppc seems to have no problem group 148s at 50 yards with fast twist barrelsjames r chapman wrote:run them out of a 10 or 12" twist....
Chris Miceli- Posts : 2715
Join date : 2015-10-27
Location : Northern Virginia
Re: 38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
PPC, it's all caps please!
(hehe)
(hehe)
james r chapman- Admin
- Posts : 6372
Join date : 2012-02-01
Age : 75
Location : HELL, Michigan
Re: 38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
Maybe too late for this train.
The HBWCs are notoriously sensitive to tipping caused by inadequate follow-through. Please review your targets for bullet holes that are not perfectly round, slightly oval, caused by a wobblely bullet.
The HBWCs are notoriously sensitive to tipping caused by inadequate follow-through. Please review your targets for bullet holes that are not perfectly round, slightly oval, caused by a wobblely bullet.
randy86314- Posts : 26
Join date : 2019-07-24
Re: 38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
Dave C,Dave C. wrote:An inch and a half at 25 yards is not a good load. Keep looking.
What group size would be a good load?
Thanks,
Ron Habegger
Colt711- Posts : 641
Join date : 2012-06-08
Age : 82
Location : Hudson, Florida
james r chapman- Admin
- Posts : 6372
Join date : 2012-02-01
Age : 75
Location : HELL, Michigan
Motophotog7 likes this post
Re: 38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
I was reading some of the experiences of the different shooters pondering the various loads for mid range loads. I was fortunate to have my shooting mentor be a quality bullet caster and we spent 30 years testing his cast bullets and comparing them to swagged HBWC bullets. I can honestly say we equaled the factory match many many times. All of my testing was from a Ransom Rest at 50 yards firing 12 shot groups. (My competition pursuits were in PPC) Unless designated, most group were loaded with 2.7 BE. I have listed below some of the better results I achieved from his bullet casting.
6" target revolver: 1-14 twist
#73 H&G SWC Many sub 2" groups. One was 1 5/8". RCBS full wadcutter: With inverted bullets, 2" with one gun and 1 5/8" with another gun. #50 H&G full wadcutter: 2"
5" target revolver: 1-10 twist
#73 H&G 1 5/8" group, RCBS SWC 1 3/8" group
Stock 686 6"
RCBS SWC 2 1/2" (11 shots 2")
Stock 586 6"
H&G #51 2 1/2" 3.4 gr. of 231
Stock Model 10 4" H&G #51 SWC 2 1/4" group & HBWC 2 1/4" group 3.9 gr. AA#5
Stock Model 686 2 1/2" 2 1/4" for 11 shots (one flyer 1" out) using factory match HbWC
My testing will be no surprise to other experienced shooters, the harder the lead alloy the faster they need to be driven.
6" target revolver: 1-14 twist
#73 H&G SWC Many sub 2" groups. One was 1 5/8". RCBS full wadcutter: With inverted bullets, 2" with one gun and 1 5/8" with another gun. #50 H&G full wadcutter: 2"
5" target revolver: 1-10 twist
#73 H&G 1 5/8" group, RCBS SWC 1 3/8" group
Stock 686 6"
RCBS SWC 2 1/2" (11 shots 2")
Stock 586 6"
H&G #51 2 1/2" 3.4 gr. of 231
Stock Model 10 4" H&G #51 SWC 2 1/4" group & HBWC 2 1/4" group 3.9 gr. AA#5
Stock Model 686 2 1/2" 2 1/4" for 11 shots (one flyer 1" out) using factory match HbWC
My testing will be no surprise to other experienced shooters, the harder the lead alloy the faster they need to be driven.
Redpen- Posts : 4
Join date : 2021-09-20
Tarm likes this post
fc60- Posts : 1458
Join date : 2011-06-11
Location : South Prairie, WA 98385
Re: 38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
Here are some better photos that show what we observed with overlays while scoring:
Clean round holes.
Out-of-round holes with offset/half grease rings.
I had some input from folks on the line indicating that had similar problems with some lots of FGMM due to low velocities. Shot great on the short line, though.
Clean round holes.
Out-of-round holes with offset/half grease rings.
I had some input from folks on the line indicating that had similar problems with some lots of FGMM due to low velocities. Shot great on the short line, though.
JRV- Posts : 201
Join date : 2022-04-04
Re: 38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
Dave,
Is the K38 barrel and early 14 barrels the same? I have a 14-3 that shoots hbwc extremely well. Everything else is a crap shoot.
Jon
Jon Eulette- Posts : 4399
Join date : 2013-04-15
Location : Southern Kalifornia
Re: 38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
@Jon,
I was gifted a bag of K38 barrels. They are all pre-EDM rifled. I picked out a nice looking one and machined it to fit my tester.
Groove diameter is 0.357" and a M52 barrel is 0.354"/0.355".
The twist would be the "normal" 1:18 3/4" in both models.
Mine is chambered with a SAAMI 38 WadCutter profile.
The goal was to test ammo with a slow twist to simulate a M52.
With the lathe turned round K38 barrel I have fired many ten-X groups at 50 yards with various bullets, weights, brands, swaged/cast, etc...
I have friends that own K38's that shoot good groups at 50 yards.
I cannot explain why one K38 shoots well while the next one does not.
Cheers,
Dave
I was gifted a bag of K38 barrels. They are all pre-EDM rifled. I picked out a nice looking one and machined it to fit my tester.
Groove diameter is 0.357" and a M52 barrel is 0.354"/0.355".
The twist would be the "normal" 1:18 3/4" in both models.
Mine is chambered with a SAAMI 38 WadCutter profile.
The goal was to test ammo with a slow twist to simulate a M52.
With the lathe turned round K38 barrel I have fired many ten-X groups at 50 yards with various bullets, weights, brands, swaged/cast, etc...
I have friends that own K38's that shoot good groups at 50 yards.
I cannot explain why one K38 shoots well while the next one does not.
Cheers,
Dave
fc60- Posts : 1458
Join date : 2011-06-11
Location : South Prairie, WA 98385
Re: 38 Special Full Wadcutter stability?
Another data point - I just started playing with short line loads for my GP100. Best one I've found so far is
2.6g WST 148g HBWC (Bear Creek - coated) roll crimp, flush to case mouth. 10 shots from the bench - with the wrong glasses for irons, all in the X-ring
Average 713 fps, SD 8.3
I think I'll be using that this year.
2.6g WST 148g HBWC (Bear Creek - coated) roll crimp, flush to case mouth. 10 shots from the bench - with the wrong glasses for irons, all in the X-ring
Average 713 fps, SD 8.3
I think I'll be using that this year.
straybrit- Posts : 389
Join date : 2012-09-05
Page 2 of 2 • 1, 2
Similar topics
» 38 Special Wadcutter Brass
» 38 Special Wadcutter Handloading Problem!
» 38 Special Wadcutter
» What .38 Special Wadcutter
» 38 special wadcutter brass
» 38 Special Wadcutter Handloading Problem!
» 38 Special Wadcutter
» What .38 Special Wadcutter
» 38 special wadcutter brass
Page 2 of 2
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum