Substitute for WW 452AA
+9
Jerry Keefer
rich.tullo
Rich/WIS
teg2658
Randy Earnest
expendable
john bickar
james r chapman
Axehandle
13 posters
Page 1 of 2
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
Substitute for WW 452AA
You old heads that loaded 452AA in your paper punchers in the 80s... You make note of what was the best replacement when it went away? A quick google says WST. I'm planning to try to come as close as I can to KCs old heavy cast bullet 38 Super load.
Axehandle- Posts : 879
Join date : 2013-09-17
Location : Alabama
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
I think you found it.
although, can you describe the "old heavy cast bullet .38 load"? are you saying 158 grain? or something for a .38/44 frame.
although, can you describe the "old heavy cast bullet .38 load"? are you saying 158 grain? or something for a .38/44 frame.
james r chapman- Admin
- Posts : 6299
Join date : 2012-01-31
Age : 75
Location : HELL, Michigan
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
Guess it could have been a 180-200 grain bullet intended for the likes of a 357 maximum couldn't it! KC's load was for a 150 grain bullet running slow like a 38 Wadcutter gun. I've got a Magnus Bullet Company 147 grain bullet to work with.
Axehandle- Posts : 879
Join date : 2013-09-17
Location : Alabama
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
Still using it ![Smile](https://2img.net/i/fa/i/smiles/icon_smile.gif)
![Smile](https://2img.net/i/fa/i/smiles/icon_smile.gif)
john bickar- Posts : 2227
Join date : 2011-07-09
Age : 100
Location : Menlo Park, CA
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
I'm still using it also.
WST was it's replacement, they are close but not the same.
WST was it's replacement, they are close but not the same.
expendable- Posts : 90
Join date : 2011-10-01
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
I also still use 452AA but I have a very limited supply and only use it for Nosler JHP's. When I first started shooting Bullseye the guy I bought my first 1911 wad gun from was using it but he was no longer shooting matches and he sold me 20lbs. I have about 1/2lb left. I tried WST but never got the same results as with the 452AA. I would sure like to know why Winchester discontinued it. I have several good friends that shoot Trap and skeet that feel the same. Anybody want to sell some?
Randy Earnest- Posts : 17
Join date : 2011-06-10
Age : 75
Location : Williamstom, S.C.
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
I was a 452AA user and did extensive testing with WST when it came out. Sold off my remaining 452AA and have used WST since. Have tried many powders the past 20 years and always end up going back to WST.
Tom Ginovsky
Tom Ginovsky
teg2658- Posts : 263
Join date : 2014-05-22
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
Using up my last 1/2 pound also, when it's gone will start using up the 4 pounds of WW 473AA I still have.
Rich/WIS- Posts : 85
Join date : 2014-07-01
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
When I use up my 230P I'm going to load up the last of my HiVel#2.
james r chapman- Admin
- Posts : 6299
Join date : 2012-01-31
Age : 75
Location : HELL, Michigan
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
Tom,
May I ask what the make up of your WST Loads. I do have some (not much) WST powder and would like to try it again.
Randy Earnest
May I ask what the make up of your WST Loads. I do have some (not much) WST powder and would like to try it again.
Randy Earnest
Randy Earnest- Posts : 17
Join date : 2011-06-10
Age : 75
Location : Williamstom, S.C.
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
Randy,
I use only Winchester LP primers, my own hand cast H&G 68 bullets sized .452 and Federal brass. 3.8 grains WST for 50 ft and 25 yd, 4.2 grains for 50 yds. For 50 yards I switched to the Nosler 185 HP, 5.0 grains WST, OAL of 1.24 inch always loaded on once fired Federal brass. I have 4 wad guns and this load shoots well in all of them at 50 yards. I also own a Ransom rest so there is no question on the results. In the early 1990s the Winchester Factory rep was at Camp Perry and I asked him how much hotter the Winchester large pistol primer was then the other makes since they only make the one instead of regular LP and magnum LP. His answer was Winchester LP primer is 8% hotter then the other standard LP primers.
Tom Ginovsky
I use only Winchester LP primers, my own hand cast H&G 68 bullets sized .452 and Federal brass. 3.8 grains WST for 50 ft and 25 yd, 4.2 grains for 50 yds. For 50 yards I switched to the Nosler 185 HP, 5.0 grains WST, OAL of 1.24 inch always loaded on once fired Federal brass. I have 4 wad guns and this load shoots well in all of them at 50 yards. I also own a Ransom rest so there is no question on the results. In the early 1990s the Winchester Factory rep was at Camp Perry and I asked him how much hotter the Winchester large pistol primer was then the other makes since they only make the one instead of regular LP and magnum LP. His answer was Winchester LP primer is 8% hotter then the other standard LP primers.
Tom Ginovsky
teg2658- Posts : 263
Join date : 2014-05-22
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
Tom,
Thanks for the information. look like good loads, close to what I tried before but with different components. I was using Winchester brass, Federal Primers and Star 200gr swaged bullets. I'll let you know how my test go, I also have a Ransom Rest but I didn't when I tried WST before.
Randy
Thanks for the information. look like good loads, close to what I tried before but with different components. I was using Winchester brass, Federal Primers and Star 200gr swaged bullets. I'll let you know how my test go, I also have a Ransom Rest but I didn't when I tried WST before.
Randy
Randy Earnest- Posts : 17
Join date : 2011-06-10
Age : 75
Location : Williamstom, S.C.
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
Randy Earnest wrote:I also still use 452AA but I have a very limited supply and only use it for Nosler JHP's.
What charge are you using for the Noslers? I looked back at some old test results that I did with 4.3 grains, and that was running about 730fps, which I think is too slow. That group was about 2.5". I am thinking maybe 4.5-4.8?
john bickar- Posts : 2227
Join date : 2011-07-09
Age : 100
Location : Menlo Park, CA
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
John,
I use 4.3 452AA @ OAL of 1.200" with the Nosler 185 JHP.It always shot around 2" from my Ransom Rest at 50 yds. I'll have to dig through my files to find my chronograph test. I have tried WST again and have used both 4.5 And 4.7, my best results have been with the 4.5 with the Nosler and the Zero JHP,s. I have not Ransom rested these loads but my scores have remained close to what I been shooting.(which has not been good lately). when I was shooting on a regular basis I used the 452AA, 4.3 at 50 yds and 3.8 at 25 yds with Valiant 200 gr SWC. I'll dig up my targets for both and try to post them later.
Randy
I use 4.3 452AA @ OAL of 1.200" with the Nosler 185 JHP.It always shot around 2" from my Ransom Rest at 50 yds. I'll have to dig through my files to find my chronograph test. I have tried WST again and have used both 4.5 And 4.7, my best results have been with the 4.5 with the Nosler and the Zero JHP,s. I have not Ransom rested these loads but my scores have remained close to what I been shooting.(which has not been good lately). when I was shooting on a regular basis I used the 452AA, 4.3 at 50 yds and 3.8 at 25 yds with Valiant 200 gr SWC. I'll dig up my targets for both and try to post them later.
Randy
Randy Earnest- Posts : 17
Join date : 2011-06-10
Age : 75
Location : Williamstom, S.C.
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
OK, thanks, maybe I'll give 4.3 another try, since that's what the Star is set up for.
john bickar- Posts : 2227
Join date : 2011-07-09
Age : 100
Location : Menlo Park, CA
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
WSTand VV320 (they tell me) I have two pounds and have not used them yet.
rich.tullo- Posts : 1975
Join date : 2015-03-27
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
Original stuff.. Full to the brim..
It has no physical resemblance to WST at all.. It is a true ball powder.
![Substitute for WW 452AA IMG_2232_zpswhf7c7yp](https://2img.net/h/i604.photobucket.com/albums/tt128/jerrykeefer/IMG_2232_zpswhf7c7yp.jpg)
It has no physical resemblance to WST at all.. It is a true ball powder.
![Substitute for WW 452AA IMG_2232_zpswhf7c7yp](https://2img.net/h/i604.photobucket.com/albums/tt128/jerrykeefer/IMG_2232_zpswhf7c7yp.jpg)
Last edited by Jerry Keefer on 11/5/2015, 12:27 pm; edited 1 time in total
Jerry Keefer- Posts : 1001
Join date : 2012-01-02
Location : Maidens, VA
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
My stash is in metal cans. I'll try to post a picture if I can ever figure out this Intertubes thingy...
john bickar- Posts : 2227
Join date : 2011-07-09
Age : 100
Location : Menlo Park, CA
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
I plan some serious testing with that keg for both 38 spl. and 45.. I have found powders that produce acceptable velocities, at low pressures, produce excellent groups.. 452AA is one such powder..231 also makes suitable FPS with low pressures..
My 10 twist 38 barrel blank is on the way from Douglas...![Smile](https://2img.net/i/fa/i/smiles/icon_smile.gif)
![Smile](https://2img.net/i/fa/i/smiles/icon_smile.gif)
My 10 twist 38 barrel blank is on the way from Douglas...
![Smile](https://2img.net/i/fa/i/smiles/icon_smile.gif)
![Smile](https://2img.net/i/fa/i/smiles/icon_smile.gif)
Jerry Keefer- Posts : 1001
Join date : 2012-01-02
Location : Maidens, VA
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
Jerry, here's the stuff I have:
![Substitute for WW 452AA 452AA-01](https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/5893100/452AA-01.jpg)
![Substitute for WW 452AA 452AA-02](https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/5893100/452AA-02.jpg)
This also may be of interest: http://www.ilrc.ucf.edu/powders/sample_detail.php?powder_id=239
![Substitute for WW 452AA 452AA-01](https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/5893100/452AA-01.jpg)
![Substitute for WW 452AA 452AA-02](https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/5893100/452AA-02.jpg)
This also may be of interest: http://www.ilrc.ucf.edu/powders/sample_detail.php?powder_id=239
john bickar- Posts : 2227
Join date : 2011-07-09
Age : 100
Location : Menlo Park, CA
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
Ah...Very nice pristine can... Yes, the granules look identical to mine.
Jerry Keefer- Posts : 1001
Join date : 2012-01-02
Location : Maidens, VA
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
[img]
[/img]Somebody PLEASE sell me 10 lbs!!. I found two target that I fired from the Ransom Rest several years ago using 4.3 grs of 452AA. I'll try to attach them to this reply.
Randy
[img]
[/img]
![Substitute for WW 452AA 4_3grs22](https://i.servimg.com/u/f21/16/56/76/14/4_3grs22.jpg)
Randy
[img]
![Substitute for WW 452AA 4_3grs23](https://i.servimg.com/u/f21/16/56/76/14/4_3grs23.jpg)
Randy Earnest- Posts : 17
Join date : 2011-06-10
Age : 75
Location : Williamstom, S.C.
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
I have found no 1:1 replacement for 452AA. WST has certainly NOT been it in my .45s. WST has been worse than TiteGroup and Clays.
I currently use 231/HP38. It has been as good across bullet weights and charge weights as 452AA. AA2 and Red Dot are close.
I currently use 231/HP38. It has been as good across bullet weights and charge weights as 452AA. AA2 and Red Dot are close.
noylj- Posts : 426
Join date : 2012-03-09
Age : 74
Location : SW USA
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
I did it. ![Substitute for WW 452AA 2935285009](/users/1914/27/52/70/smiles/2935285009.gif)
![Substitute for WW 452AA 2935285009](/users/1914/27/52/70/smiles/2935285009.gif)
Randy Earnest- Posts : 17
Join date : 2011-06-10
Age : 75
Location : Williamstom, S.C.
Re: Substitute for WW 452AA
Maybe I should've put a rolled-up hundred-dollar-bill in that second photo - that might more accurately depict shooters' attitude towards 452AA ![Very Happy](https://2img.net/i/fa/i/smiles/icon_biggrin.png)
![Very Happy](https://2img.net/i/fa/i/smiles/icon_biggrin.png)
john bickar- Posts : 2227
Join date : 2011-07-09
Age : 100
Location : Menlo Park, CA
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
![-](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif)
» Shot 452AA for first time recently
» Substitute for .22 in competition?
» Substitute for Zero 185gr JHP
» Good substitute for Hornady 148 gr HBWC?
» For 9mm Luger, can one substitute the sizing die for a taper crimp die?
» Substitute for .22 in competition?
» Substitute for Zero 185gr JHP
» Good substitute for Hornady 148 gr HBWC?
» For 9mm Luger, can one substitute the sizing die for a taper crimp die?
Page 1 of 2
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|